Car accidents during snowstorms are unfortunately common in New York, where icy roads and limited visibility create dangerous driving conditions. As the weather worsens, many drivers may struggle to navigate safely, which can lead to accidents. In such cases, proving fault becomes complicated. Weather conditions play a significant role, but they don’t automatically absolve a driver from responsibility. Knowing how to prove fault when a snowstorm is involved is essential for ensuring that victims are properly compensated.
In New York, snowstorm accidents often present a unique challenge in determining fault. With the ever-changing weather, drivers are expected to adjust their behavior accordingly. However, it is not always clear when one party’s actions are negligent, especially when both drivers claim that the snowstorm was the cause of the accident. In this guide, we’ll explore how fault is determined in snowstorm car accidents in New York, what you need to prove to hold someone accountable, and the legal steps to take after such an incident.
Robert Friedman
Michael Ranzenhofer
Justin Friedman
John Dracup
Understanding Fault in Snowstorm Accidents 
In most car accidents, determining fault is straightforward: the driver who caused the accident is deemed responsible. Fault in an accident can stem from various factors, such as distracted driving, speeding, or running a red light. In the case of a snowstorm, however, it becomes more complicated because the weather conditions play a significant role. While snow, ice, and reduced visibility are contributing factors, they don’t automatically exonerate a driver who failed to adapt to the circumstances.
In New York, drivers are required to follow a reasonable standard of care, which means they must drive in a way that minimizes risk to others, especially in adverse conditions. This includes reducing speed, keeping a safe following distance, and ensuring that their vehicle is in good working condition for winter driving. Drivers must also use their vehicle’s lights and wipers appropriately during a snowstorm. If a driver is speeding or fails to take the necessary precautions despite the snowstorm, they could still be held liable for the accident.
Weather Conditions and Liability
Weather conditions certainly impact how an accident occurs, but New York law does not give drivers a free pass when poor weather is involved. Instead, the key question is whether the driver’s actions were reasonable under the conditions they were facing. In other words, even in a snowstorm, drivers are expected to adjust their speed, direction, and general driving behavior to match the conditions.
For example, if a driver is speeding through a snowstorm, driving too fast for the road conditions, and causes an accident, they may still be found at fault. Snowstorms cause slippery roads, decreased visibility, and longer braking distances. In these conditions, it’s expected that drivers slow down, increase the distance between their vehicle and others, and stay vigilant for any hazards on the road.
The liability of a driver in a snowstorm accident largely depends on whether they failed to meet the standard of care expected in such weather. If they were driving aggressively or didn’t take appropriate actions to ensure their safety or the safety of others, they may be found negligent.
The Role of Comparative Fault in Snowstorm Accidents
New York operates under a comparative fault rule, meaning that even if both parties are partially responsible for an accident, the damages can be divided based on the percentage of fault each person holds. For example, if one driver is found to be 70% at fault for an accident, while the other driver is 30% at fault, the driver found less at fault would only be responsible for their share of the damages. This is important when snowstorm accidents are involved because multiple factors can contribute to the accident, including both drivers’ behavior and the weather conditions.
For example, if one driver was driving at an unsafe speed during a snowstorm, but the other driver failed to properly maintain their vehicle or didn’t use their lights, both could be partially responsible. In such cases, a determination of comparative fault would be made, and each driver would be assigned a percentage of responsibility.
Proving Fault in Snowstorm Car Accidents
In order to prove fault in a snowstorm-related accident, evidence needs to be gathered from various sources. Here are some of the ways fault can be determined in such cases:
- Police Reports
When an accident occurs, police typically arrive on the scene to investigate. Their report will detail what happened during the accident, who was involved, and the statements given by each driver. A police report can provide valuable insight into how the accident occurred and whether either driver was violating any traffic laws or driving unsafely. - Witness Statements
Witnesses who saw the accident can also provide important testimony. If there were bystanders who saw the accident unfold, their statements can help corroborate one driver’s version of events. Witnesses may also be able to describe the road conditions and weather during the incident. - Weather Data
The weather conditions during the snowstorm can be crucial in proving fault. Weather data, such as snowfall rates, temperature, and visibility, can help assess whether the drivers were driving reasonably in relation to the conditions at the time. This data can often be obtained from local weather stations or online sources. - Dash Cam or Surveillance Footage
If available, footage from dash cameras or nearby surveillance cameras can provide a clear picture of how the accident happened. Video footage can show the actions of both drivers, road conditions, and other factors that contributed to the accident. In snowstorm accidents, this evidence can be especially helpful in showing whether one driver was speeding or if their vehicle was struggling to maintain control in the weather. - Accident Reconstruction
In some cases, experts may be called in to reconstruct the accident. These experts can analyze the scene, road conditions, vehicle damage, and other factors to determine how the crash occurred and which driver was at fault. This process can be vital when the circumstances are unclear or when both drivers are claiming that weather conditions were the primary cause.
Will My Personal Injury Case Go To Trial? Choosing a Personal Injury AttorneyRelated Videos
Dealing with Insurance Companies
If you are involved in a snowstorm accident, the next step is typically filing a claim with your insurance company. New York is a no-fault state, which means that your own insurance company will cover your medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who caused the accident. However, if the accident caused serious injuries or property damage, you may need to pursue a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance.
Insurance companies may attempt to reduce their payouts or deny claims by arguing that weather conditions were the primary cause of the accident. It’s important to have strong evidence to support your claim, such as witness statements, weather records, and police reports. An experienced attorney can help you navigate the claims process and ensure that you are fairly compensated.
How Lawyers Can Help Prove Fault in Snowstorm Accidents
Proving fault in a snowstorm car accident can be complex, but having the right legal representation can make a significant difference. An attorney who is familiar with New York’s personal injury laws can help gather the evidence needed to establish fault, negotiate with insurance companies, and ensure that you receive the compensation you deserve.
If you have been involved in a snowstorm accident and need help proving fault, an experienced personal injury lawyer at Friedman & Ranzenhofer can assist you every step of the way. We understand the challenges involved in weather-related accidents and will work tirelessly to protect your rights and hold the responsible party accountable.
Snowstorm car accidents in New York present unique challenges when it comes to proving fault. Weather conditions undeniably play a role, but drivers must still take reasonable care when operating their vehicles in adverse conditions. If you have been injured or involved in an accident during a snowstorm, it is essential to understand your rights and seek legal assistance to ensure that fault is properly established and that you are fairly compensated.
At Friedman & Ranzenhofer, we are committed to helping you navigate the complexities of personal injury claims, especially when weather conditions are involved. Our experienced attorneys are here to provide guidance and support to help you recover and get the compensation you deserve.