NY Trust Beneficiary Who Requests Information Violates The No- Contest Clause

NY Trust Beneficiary Who Requests Information Violates The No- Contest ClauseNew York living (intervivos) trusts have become more prevalent for estate planning purposes in recent years and increasingly contain no-contest (“in terrorem”) clauses intended to prevent challenges to the instruments’ validity. In order to fill the statutory void that currently exists, The New York State Bar Association Trusts & Estates Law Section recommended on October 31, 2026, that NY EPTL 3-3.5  be amended to include safe harbor provisions that apply to both wills and intervivos trusts. Moreover, amending NY SCPA 1404 will provide a formal mechanism by which an individual could obtain limited pre-objection discovery from the person who drafted an intervivos trust associated with a pour-over will without being subject to forfeiture. The New York State Bar Association Trusts & Estates Law Section recommends that  SCPA 1404 should be amended to ensure that an individual is afforded the opportunity to obtain information from the person who drafted the inter vivos trust in the event the will devises or bequeaths a portion of the estate to a trust.

Under existing New York law, individuals who receive assets under a will may lose their inheritance if they challenge that will, due to so-called “no-contest” (in terrorem) clauses. At the same time, the law recognizes that beneficiaries need a fair opportunity to gather information and evaluate whether a challenge is justified. To address this, Estates, Powers, and Trusts Law (“EPTL”) § 3-3.5 establishes “safe harbor” protections that allow certain limited actions—such as obtaining relevant information—without triggering a forfeiture. However, these protections apply only to wills and do not clearly extend to inter vivos trusts even though trusts are now widely used as primary estate planning tools and often function as substitutes for wills. As a result, beneficiaries of trusts may face significant legal risk for engaging in the same reasonable conduct that is expressly protected in the context of a will. This proposed NY legislation addresses that gap by extending existing safe harbor protections to trusts. Doing so will promote consistency in the law, reduce uncertainty for families and courts, and ensure that beneficiaries can responsibly evaluate their rights and seek appropriate oversight without undue risk of forfeiting their inheritance.

Consistent with NY EPTL 11-1.7, which provides that attempts to exonerate a fiduciary from liability is against public policy, the safe harbor provisions should also be expanded to provide clarity that attempts by beneficiaries to compel fiduciaries to account do not trigger forfeiture. In addition to the EPTL, New York case law provides significant support for such an expansion. For example, in Matter of Merenstein, the New York County Surrogate’s Court expressly held that petitions for accountings under SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206 would not trigger forfeiture under an in terrorem clause Other Surrogate’s Courts, including Erie County Surrogate’s Court and Suffolk County Surrogate’s Court, have similarly held that compelling a fiduciary to account would not trigger an in terrorem clause. Most recently, in holding that a beneficiary did not violate an in terrorem clause, the Court of Appeals held that the beneficiary’s request for an accounting was within her legal rights.

If you are considering contesting a will or trust in New York, the probate legal team at Friedman & Ranzenhofer, PC is here to help. Our experienced attorneys have a deep understanding of New York’s probate laws and are dedicated to providing compassionate and effective legal representation. We will work tirelessly to protect your rights and ensure that your voice is heard. Call or text  Friedman & Ranzenhofer, PC today at (716) 543-3764 to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward resolving your will contest. Let us guide you through this challenging process and help you achieve the best possible outcome.

NY Trust Beneficiary Who Requests Information Violates The No- Contest Clause

New York living (intervivos) trusts have become more prevalent for estate planning purposes in recent years and increasingly contain no-contest (“in terrorem”) clauses intended to prevent challenges to the instruments’ validity. In order to fill the statutory void that currently exists, The New York State Bar Association Trusts & Estates Law Section recommended on October 31, 2026, that NY EPTL 3-3.5  be amended to include safe harbor provisions that apply to both wills and intervivos trusts. Moreover, amending NY SCPA 1404 will provide a formal mechanism by which an individual could obtain limited pre-objection discovery from the person who drafted an intervivos trust associated with a pour-over will without being subject to forfeiture. The New York State Bar Association Trusts & Estates Law Section recommends that  SCPA 1404 should be amended to ensure that an individual is afforded the opportunity to obtain information from the person who drafted the inter vivos trust in the event the will devises or bequeaths a portion of the estate to a trust.

Under existing New York law, individuals who receive assets under a will may lose their inheritance if they challenge that will, due to so-called “no-contest” (in terrorem) clauses. At the same time, the law recognizes that beneficiaries need a fair opportunity to gather information and evaluate whether a challenge is justified. To address this, Estates, Powers, and Trusts Law (“EPTL”) § 3-3.5 establishes “safe harbor” protections that allow certain limited actions—such as obtaining relevant information—without triggering a forfeiture. However, these protections apply only to wills and do not clearly extend to inter vivos trusts even though trusts are now widely used as primary estate planning tools and often function as substitutes for wills. As a result, beneficiaries of trusts may face significant legal risk for engaging in the same reasonable conduct that is expressly protected in the context of a will. This proposed NY legislation addresses that gap by extending existing safe harbor protections to trusts. Doing so will promote consistency in the law, reduce uncertainty for families and courts, and ensure that beneficiaries can responsibly evaluate their rights and seek appropriate oversight without undue risk of forfeiting their inheritance.

Consistent with NY EPTL 11-1.7, which provides that attempts to exonerate a fiduciary from liability is against public policy, the safe harbor provisions should also be expanded to provide clarity that attempts by beneficiaries to compel fiduciaries to account do not trigger forfeiture. In addition to the EPTL, New York case law provides significant support for such an expansion. For example, in Matter of Merenstein, the New York County Surrogate’s Court expressly held that petitions for accountings under SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206 would not trigger forfeiture under an in terrorem clause Other Surrogate’s Courts, including Erie County Surrogate’s Court and Suffolk County Surrogate’s Court, have similarly held that compelling a fiduciary to account would not trigger an in terrorem clause. Most recently, in holding that a beneficiary did not violate an in terrorem clause, the Court of Appeals held that the beneficiary’s request for an accounting was within her legal rights.

If you are considering contesting a will or trust in New York, the probate legal team at Friedman & Ranzenhofer, PC is here to help. Our experienced attorneys have a deep understanding of New York’s probate laws and are dedicated to providing compassionate and effective legal representation. We will work tirelessly to protect your rights and ensure that your voice is heard. Call or text  Friedman & Ranzenhofer, PC today at (716) 543-3764 to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward resolving your will contest. Let us guide you through this challenging process and help you achieve the best possible outcome.